Hope in a Darkening Age...
news, comment, arts, ecology, wisdom, obsessions, the past, the future...
"THE END OF ALL INTELLIGENT ANALYSIS IS TO CLEAR THE WAY FOR SYNTHESIS."--H.G. Wells. "It's always a leap into the unknown future to write anything."--Margaret Atwood "Be kind, be useful, be fearless."--President Barack Obama.
Friday, August 12, 2011
This Crisis Can't Be "Solved"
I don't know where this little audio clip is from, it sounds like a speakerphone, but it's clear Al has had enough of denialism and its cost. It's going to sound hysterical to denialists but those who are equally frustrated with the pernicious effects of the heavy financed denialist campaign (carried out by the same people who ran the tobacco companies' campaign denying that smoking was bad for you, using the same methods--which is what Gore is talking about as this clip begins) can only identify with his anger.
Al Gore has done a lot to spotlight this crucial issue, and his Climate Reality Project kicks off in September. He also did a lot to re-name this the Climate Crisis, which better communicates the urgency than the less than riveting "global warming," "greenhouse effect" or "climate change." But he's also behind what I consider an unfortunate and inaccurate description of the task at hand. He calls it "solving the Climate Crisis." He started it, and even Bill McKibben has adopted it. But it's wrong.
First of all, there's a category error. You don't solve a crisis. You address or confront a crisis. You solve a problem. This is more than just jarring to the ear. It suggests that this crisis is just one problem. It's much more than that. Plus it suggests that it can be solved--that is, that it is a solution that will make it all go away. There is no such solution. There are problems responsible for the crisis that can be addressed, and some problems that can be solved. But we are experiencing the Climate Crisis now, in its early stages. We are going to be experiencing the acceleration of the Climate Crisis for years, and nothing will prevent it. We must address the problems that arise because of it--the effects in the present and near future. We must confront the worsening crisis in the farther future by solving the problems of how to maintain a civilization while radically reducing greenhouse gases emissions, and restoring the environment that sustains life on land and in the water, and perhaps even our atmosphere.
I call it dealing with effects and with causes. Mark Hertsgaard calls it playing defense (in the short-term) and offense (for the long-term.) The tonedeaf call it adaptation and mitigation. But together they are the zones of activity to confront the Climate Crisis for the next century or likely more. The problems involved in confronting this crisis are in such areas as flood control, public health, clean energy technology, economic reorganization--well, eventually just about everything. Not exactly a range that makes "solution" or "solve" a very meaningful term.
Those are multiple problems that can be addressed with varying degrees of success--with smaller problems "solved" along the way--by many people doing different things. (If you're looking for good news, this is probably it--a lot of people will have something truly meaningful to do with their lives, and many kinds of talent will be needed.) But we begin by recognizing, confronting and addressing the Climate Crisis. While it's true that much can be done without even mentioning the Climate Crisis, it's unlikely we're going to be able to avoid confronting it for long.
While Warriors Watch
-
The first round of the NBA playoffs is over, with some Western Conference
surprises, at least in terms of pre-season hopes and expectations. The
bigges...
Howdy Doodle
-
It was four summers ago—nearly five—that Margaret drove the six hours or so
to the Bay Area, to an animal shelter that specialized in small dogs,
espe...
N. Scott Momaday 1934-2024
-
N. Scott Momaday, poet, novelist, playwright, artist, essayist, scholar
and teacher, died in January. He is best known for his first novel, *House
Mad...
Strange Old Worlds
-
On September 8, 1966 the first season of the Star Trek series began. It
explored strange new worlds in the galaxy of imagination as well as in
televis...
Legacy of the Carnegie Libraries
-
The centennial celebration in 2004 of the Carnegie Library in Eureka, CA,
transformed into the Morris Graves Museum of Art a few years earlier, was
the occ...
1 year ago
The Malling of America
available at your online bookseller
Manifesto
..."The answer that led those who have been told for so long by so many to be cynical, and fearful, and doubtful of what we can achieve, to put their hands on the arc of history and bend it once more toward the hope of a better day."--Barack Obama Nov. 4, 2008
"Now, there are some who question the scale of our ambitions - who suggest that our system cannot tolerate too many big plans. Their memories are short. For they have forgotten what this country has already done; what free men and women can achieve when imagination is joined to common purpose, and necessity to courage." Barack Obama January 20, 2009
"If you turn away now – if you buy into the cynicism that the change we fought for isn’t possible…well, change will not happen. If you give up on the idea that your voice can make a difference, then other voices will fill the void: lobbyists and special interests; the people with the $10 million checks who are trying to buy this election and those who are making it harder for you to vote; Washington politicians who want to decide who you can marry, or control health care choices that women should make for themselves. Only you can make sure that doesn't happen. Only you have the power to move us forward.--President Obama on Sept. 6, 2012
No comments:
Post a Comment